In an attempt to systematize the fighting abilities of characters from different universes, I have below listed those elements that are considered important. For instance, whereas the natural swordfighting abilities are of importance in the Star Wars universe, athletic prowess and strength seem to be foremost in DC and Marvel. In all universes, knowledge of individual fighting styles are significant, though the names of those styles may vary. I have found that the simplest way to measure and compare abilities is by the following formulae:
Swordsmanship + Damage + style points + DPT + APT
Athletics + Swordsmanship 12345672SwBow4SwWhTK
Forms 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 2Swords Bow 4Swords Whip Empty handfighting
1:1 1:1×2 1:0 2×1:1×2 0:1 1:1 2×1:1×2 2×1:1×2 2×1:1 2×1:1×2 2×1:1 1:1×1/5
Damage = Swordsmanship + Damage bonuses and detriments
1 = -5; 5 = +10; Bow = -5
Yoda 99 655935400000
Luke Skywalker 97 305650800000
Darth Sidious 94 553655800000
Darth Tyrannus 90 393333300000
Darth Krayt 88 300003540000
Darth Maul 87 300400507005
Mace Windu 86 555555900000
Revan 86 543700400000
Kit Fisto 85 901000000000
Galen Marek 85 402460300000
Exar Kun 84 300430047000
Ganner Rhysode 84 785000000000
Darth Sion 82 500000700000
Naga Sadow 82 360040700000
Kyle Katarn 81 350030600000
Obi-Wan Kenobi 81 308304000000
Kol Skywalker 80 406000300000
Even Piell 79 901000000000
Qui-Gon Jinn 79 400670000000
Anakin Skywalker 78 324540000000
Nomi Sunrider 78 507500000000
Uliq Qel-Droma 78 400060400000
Meetra Sutra 77 333430060004
Voolvif Monn 75 600730000000
Asajj Ventress 74 360003040000
Arden Lyn 74 600004800009
Belia Darzu 74 050300860000
Saesee Tiin 74 500070000000
Lord Hoth 73 503060000000
Shaak Ti 73 405300220000
Darth Bane 72 450090600000
Darth Nihl 72 000000860000
Darth Talon 72 500030800000
K’Kruhk 72 406050000000
Lucien Draay 72 705000000000
Mara Jade 71 310200240004
Rakatan Warrior 70 555555507000
Kyp Durron 69 300320500000
Darth Malak 68 350040000000
Darth Vader 68 324560000000
Quinlan Vos 68 320430700000
Agen Kolar 67 440060000000
Plo Koon 67 900070000005
Depa Billaba 65 555555900000
Mira 64 304503000000
Thon 64 506630000009
An’ya Kuro 63 304530000000
Jarael 63 100000002000
Antares Draco 62 500070000000
Leia Organa-Solo 62 303430540000
Lumiya 62 320400300503
Shado Vao 62 547040004000
Jaina Solo 61 303020000002
Stass Allie 61 405003000000
Grievous 60 333333330300
Jacen Solo 58 302060000000
Luminara Unduli 58 305020000000
Rahm Kota 57 405000600000
Visas Marr 57 030000600000
Carnor Jax 56 300020405000
Wolf Sazen 56 406000000000
Juhani 55 300220000000
Ayala Secura 54 300520020000
Roan Fel 54 504040000000
Bastila Shan 53 400520005000
Darth Nihilius 53 001700000000
Freedon Nadd 53 330440500000
Roni von Wasaki 53 764000050000
Ki-Adi-Mundi 52 300040000000
Kreia 52 305000003000
Veda Kennede 52 333333305003
Atris 51 305006000000
Corran Horn 51 302000000004
Valara Saar 51 500000000007
Coleman Trebor 48 500006000000
Marasiah Fel 48 304020000000
Mical 48 305002000000
Darth Plagueis 47 533333300000
Sly Moore 47 300000200000
Atton Rand 46 300005200000
Barriss Offee 44 303020000000
Darth Bandon 44 300050003000
Bao-dur 43 305000000000
Jolee Bindo 43 304000300000
Anakin Solo 41 304303030000
Komari Vosa 41 300003030000
Kazdan Paratus 40 304300000000
Vodo-Siosk Baas 38 901000000000
Cade Skywalker 36 303000300000
Zayne Carrick 36 300000000000
Maris Brood 34 303000040000
Charal 34 102030000000
Nahdar Vebb 34 402000000000
Cay Qel-Droma 31 304500000000
Roron Corobb 30 303000000000
Zuckuss 28 200000000000
Ahsoka Tano 26 200020000000
Ferus Olin 25 403000000000
Ephant Mon 23 000010000000
Jax Pavan 22 201000000000
Jagged Fel 19 301000000000
Ulaha Kore 17 100000000000
Soontir Fel 12 100000000000
Wicket Warrick 9 100000000000
Grael 8 100000000000
Teebo 7 100000000000
BoShek 7 100000000000
Athletic Strength Primary Secondary Specialty Armor Shield
Blade 10 4400 0050035 000000300000000 0000000300 2 0
She-Hulk 9 620,000 0000020 000000000000000 0000000000 150 0
Ultron 9 200,000 0000020 000000000000030 0004000000 400 0
Namor 9 180,000 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 20 0
Beast 9 20,000 0095040 000000000000000 0000000007 0 0
Miracle Man 9 2000 0000000 040630000000000 0000000000 0 0
Spider-Man 9 1200 0002020 000000000000000 0000000009 1 0
Daredevil 9 200 0000400 008030400000000 0000005000 0 0
Thor 8 500,000 0000070 700000000000000 0000000000 900 0
Wonder Woman 8 400,000 3055000 000000300005000 0700000000 18 0
Loki 8 10,000 0000022 000000000000000 0000000000 900 0
Captain America 8 1400 0606510 000000000050500 0000000090 0 250
U.S. Agent 8 800 0303310 000000000040300 0000000070 0 250
Black Cat 7 900 0050010 000000050000000 0000000000 0 0
Green Goblin 7 500 0000040 500000000003002 0000000000 3 0
Black Panther 7 300 0057000 050555500000500 0050000000 180 0
Mystique 6 100 0050010 000000050000000 0000000000 0 0
Sabertooth 5 4000 0500000 000000000044030 0050000000 0 0
Wolverine 5 2700 0550555 050005000000005 0080050000 0 0
Batman 5 500 9995908 990090099909099 0000090000 2 0
The Wasp 4 500 0201110 000100000000000 0000000000 2 0
Green Arrow 4 300 0035613 000000000003000 0000000000 0 0
Robin 4 200 0809800 509080080808088 0000080800 2 0
Quake 4 150 5334220 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Batgirl 4 100 0024200 603000000000000 0000000000 2 0
Red Skull 4 100 0000000 000000000020000 0000000000 0 0
Storm 4 100 0334234 020232200000202 0000040000 0 0
Hulk 3 900,000 0000050 000000000000000 0000000000 920 0
Hercules 3 600,000 0300300 000000000000003 0000000000 21 0
Black Adam 3 550,000 0800067 000000000000000 0000000000 100 0
Colossus 3 200,000 3311432 000000000000000 0004000000 80 0
Bane 3 6000 0750090 000500005500006 0000000000 0 0
Aquaman 3 3500 0000030 000000000000000 0000000000 10 0
Moon Knight 3 800 0404040 302330000500000 0000002000 0 0
Rogue 3 600 0040010 000000000000000 0000000000 2 1
Star-Lord 3 600 0430050 000000000040000 0000000000 0 0
Hawkman 3 600 0000000 000000000030000 0009000000 2 0
The Blob 3 500 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 4 0
Cyclops 3 200 4002400 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Green Lantern 3 200 0000030 000000000020000 0000000000 0 0
Nick Fury 3 200 0030000 000004000030000 0000000000 0 0
Solo 3 200 0000340 000000200020000 0000000000 0 0
Invisible Woman3 100 0000010 000000000000000 0000020000 90 0
Darkseid 2 650,000 0000020 000000000000000 0000000000 1000 0
Superman 2 600,000 0000040 000000000000000 0000000000 1000 0
Supergirl 2 400,000 0300030 000000000003000 0000000000 1000 0
Ghost Rider 2 50,000 0000020 000000000000000 0000000000 240 0
Iron Man 2 10,000 0000010 000000000000000 0005000000 40 0
Aaron Stack 2 4000 0000020 000000000000000 0000000000 160 0
Ra’s al Ghul 2 200 9993099 730050093309697 0000090000 0 0
Ant-Man 2 200 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Blazing Skull 2 150 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Sinestro 2 150 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Talia al Ghul 2 120 9700775 739560073305643 0000050000 0 0
Cypher 2 100 0000010 000050000000000 0000000000 0 0
Dr. Strange 2 100 0230200 000000002000020 0000020000 0 0
Emma Frost 2 100 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Empath 2 100 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Gideon 2 100 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Jean Grey 2 100 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 20 0
Joker 2 100 0001010 000000400000000 0000000000 0 0
Lightspeed 2 100 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Raven 2 100 000040 000000000004000 0000000000 0 0
Tarot 2 100 0000011 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Apocalypse 1 400,000 4000000 000070000000000 0000000000 500 0
Brainiac 1 100 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Mr. Fantastic 1 100 0000340 000500000000000 0000000000 0 0
Lex Luthor 1 100 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 35 0
Professor X 1 100 0030010 000000000010000 0000000000 0 0
The Leader 1 100 0000010 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Mxyzptlk 1 50 0000000 000000000000000 0000000000 0 0
Cian Beirdd 